Can't Win Every Time...
The tricky thing about cocktails is there are so many of them. I bet there was a time when books full of cocktail recipes weren't all that common, except behind a commercial bar, but that is a time long past. Today, there is no shortage of resources for anyone looking to whip up a few stout drinks. A quick search for "cocktail recipe book" on Amazon.com leads to 4,184 results, over five hundred of which were published in the last year. That's a lot of cocktails. Add in the thousands of apps, websites, blogs, and junk-you-wish-would-quit-popping-up-in-your-Facebook-feed, and the net result is a vast landscape of delectable, distilled distractions for even the most disquisitive dilettante. (Blogging Pro-Tip: Alliteration is endearing; calling attention to it, less-so.)
My point is: we really are spoiled for choice these days. It is the perfect time to start exploring cocktails, because the possibilities are nearly endless. I considered writing a blog post describing all of the different places I look to find new cocktails, but I'm not sure it would be that enlightening. You could probably guess most of it without any hints.
No, seriously. Go on... Try it.
Close your eyes and guess.
I'll wait.
...
Did you guess "some kind of book" and/or "Google"? If so, congratulations. I knew you could do it.
So I'm not going to write a blog post about all the different places I look for cocktails, but I do want to highlight one book, in particular. Partially because this week's cocktail comes from this book, but primarily because it is a major contributor to my obsession with mixed drinks.
Written by the apparently-legendary Jim Meehan (I say "apparently" because I'd never heard of him, but I'm like Jon Snow in this equation) and documenting the impressive selection of cocktails available at the Please Don't Tell speakeasy in New York City, the PDT Cocktail Book is a treasure trove of tempting titillations and tasty treats to tickle your taste buds. It's not always an easy book to mix from, due to how crazy and obscure the ingredients can be, but it is a heck of a lot of fun. Even better, it has a companion app that tracks your bar inventory, tells you what you can make with what you have on-hand, and even suggests the next bottle you should buy to best improve your selection. That latter feature is a real killer for someone like me, with a collector's mentality. I never really played Pokemon (except for the 17 minutes that Pokemon Go was popular), but in the case of weird booze, I evidently gotta catch 'em all. Thank you, Mr. Meehan, for that large bottle of saffron liqueur sitting at the back of my liquor cabinet wondering if it will ever be used again.
The flip side of all this experimenting is that not all cocktails can be winners. Whether classic, contemporary, experimental, or avant garde, there are drinks I will try that I will regret. It is inevitable (and, let's be honest, not really all that surprising--my inexperienced palate is about as refined as a bag of Cheetos). But, I've decided not to limit this blog only to cocktails I enjoy or would want to recommend. My intent is to document my journey, and it would be an incomplete diary if I hid the missteps that are bound to occur along the way. Plus, learning from mistakes is a thing.
Which leads us to this week's cocktail:
The Drink: Purple Rain
Ingredients Used:
- Wild Turkey 101 proof Kentucky Straight Bourbon - 1.5 oz
- Madeira - 0.75 oz
- Rothman & Winter Creme de Violette - 0.5 oz
- Lemon Juice - 0.5 oz
- Pineapple Juice - 0.5 oz
I had two reasons I wanted to try the Purple Rain cocktail. First and foremost, though I'm not a big fan of Wild Turkey bourbon, I bought a very large jug of it last November to use as a base for homemade bitters, and I wanted to find some bourbon cocktails to finish off the bottle (which means I was already in the kind of mindset where you make weird casseroles to empty your pantry and fridge). Second, I wanted something very colorful for the blog this week. In my last two posts, I shared cocktails that are quite distinct in character and flavor but look very similar. To anyone just visiting the blog for the pictures (ha!), it might even look like I featured the same drink two weeks in a row. Something clear, over ice, with lime.
When I ran across the Purple Rain while flipping through PDT Cocktails, I knew I had what I was looking for. Bourbon base, check. Colorful, very. Just look at the recipe photo:
More red than purple, maybe, but that is an attractive drink! I wasn't really sure how the listed ingredients could possibly combine to make such a rich red-violet color, but I assumed the magic was in the mix. After all, the cocktail calls for Creme de Violette to help achieve its wonderful color, and that is a very purple ingredient:
Without a color wheel handy, I decided to trust Mr. Meehan and take the dive. Maybe brown + brown + yellow + violet = purple?
The Prep:
The Purple Rain is another simple drink to mix. All ingredients are added together to a cocktail shaker with ice, then shaken vigorously. Once shaken, strain into a chilled coupe glass and garnish with a brandied cherry (such as Luxardo's).
I shared the most important tip regarding cocktail shaking last week (i.e., smiling for your guests and looking cool), but maybe you're wondering why some cocktails are shaken and some aren't? Thanks to James Bond, everyone in the world knows cocktails can be shaken, or they can be stirred. I'm not sure why spies like to muddy up their martinis by shaking them, but here's the basic rule of thumb: If the cocktail has fruit juices or opaque ingredients, it is generally shaken; if it has only clear ingredients and no juices, it is generally stirred. Shaking the cocktail introduces a lot of air and will froth up the drink, and this is desirable for cocktails with juice. Conversely, clear, non-juice cocktails are best stirred because they maintain their clarity--both in appearance and texture.
You may also hear people suggest that shaking a martini can "bruise" the gin, but I don't know anything about that. It adds a lot of bubbles and makes the drink less clear, but I've never tried a shaken martini that tasted like it was hurt. As far as I know my gins are completely healthy, and they've been shaken a lot.
One more quick tip, while we're here: You may notice in the picture above that my cocktail glass is filled with ice. The Purple Rain cocktail is not served over ice, but it is still a good idea to leave some ice in your cocktail glass while you are mixing the ingredients. Pre-chilling the glass does wonders to keep your drink cold once poured, and most cocktails are intended to be enjoyed as cold as possible. Just drop some ice cubes into your glass before you start measuring and mixing your cocktail, and when you're ready to pour, drop the ice back into your ice bin. This will give you a nice, chilly glass with very little time or effort:
Some folks buy chillers for their glassware (which sounds excessive but awesome), but you can achieve the same results by using ice or popping the glasses in the freezer pre-pour. |
Ah, so all of this sounds wonderful. Tasty ingredients, a colorful goal, a nice, chilly glass. Should have been perfect--what could possibly go wrong?
Well, I invite you to look once again at Mr. Meehan's beautiful picture above, bask in that deep, red glow, recall my goal of coming up with something equally bright and colorful... and then, take a good long look at what came pouring out of my cocktail shaker:
Witness the reality of the Purple Rain. Far from the sexy, scarlet sip suggested by Mr. Meehan, the concoction I ended up with was more of a greenish-gray funk. Less "Purple Rain" and more "Actual Rain." Not exactly a good look (note my valiant attempts to add color by swapping the brandied cherry for a lemon wedge and using a purple-jeweled pick).
I am not entirely sure where this went wrong, but I actually did make it twice to confirm I hadn't screwed something up. I don't know why I thought doing the exact same thing twice would yield different results, especially since I already knew brown + brown + yellow + [really pretty much anything] would never = red or purple, but I tried it again, anyway. Same results.
This is a seriously ugly drink, folks. Thoroughly unappealing. In fairness, I will point out that the PDT Cocktail Book does specify very particular ingredients for this one, including Blandy's Rainwater Madeira, Maker's Mark bourbon, and Creme Yvette (instead of Creme de Violette). But in my defense, the PDT companion app suggested all of my substitutions, and I'm not convinced a couple of different brands would have had much effect on the color of this drink. Especially not when one of those ingredients is actually called "Rainwater."
The good news is the drink isn't really that bad, once you get past its looks. The combo of the pineapple and lemon juice makes it very acidic, and the lemon is right up on top of the palate, but it tastes okay. The Creme de Violette is completely lost, and I suspect it was just added for the color (hard fail), but the bourbon comes through as the backbone of the drink. If you like bourbon cocktails, this one might be worth a look. It is not a cocktail that really makes whisky shine (unlike next week's feature), but it's not awful. My biggest problem with it is it looks like I should wash dishes in it.